3%; I have doubts, I feel that I do believe in God, 16

Canada Goose Outlet How religious are American professors Canada Goose Outlet

canadian goose jacket candidate Amarnath Amarasingham, and as a link at Templeton Big Questions Online site. Why canada goose outlet vancouver the attention? Because the canada goose outlet factory study, published in Sociology of Religion by Neil Gross at the University of British Columbia and Solon Simmons at George Mason University, supposedly shows that American professors are nowhere near as Godless canada goose outlet michigan as people think. That seems to hearten canada goose outlet las vegas people who worry that American higher education is infested with nefarious atheists. They cite no surveys of this nor give any data themselves. They merely assert that Americans think that professors are all raving atheists. And the data show that that not the case, though professors prove to be far less religious than the public at large. canadian goose jacket

Canada Goose Parka The Gross and Simmons study canada goose jacket outlet sale has a long and boring introduction about the incursion of religion in American universities and of secularism in the faculty. And their study has a curious motivation: not to find out the degree of atheism among professors, but to show that it not canada goose outlet location pervasive. Canada Goose canada goose outlet Parka

Our aim in undertaking this largely descriptive endeavor is precisely to cast doubt on assumptions of faculty atheism, not because we ourselves have any interest in advancing a religious agenda, but because such assumptions have kept a range of important sociological questions about the processes and mechanisms responsible for the distribution of religious views in academe, as well as about the potential consequences of religiosity for teaching, research, and other faculty attitudes from being given the attention they deserve.

Canada Goose sale That just weird: no real science paper would have as its aim to demonstrate a certain phenomenon. Presumably studies like this are supposed to canada goose outlet houston find the truth, not doubt. What did they find? They surveyed 1417 professors at American colleges and universities (including junior colleges), sampling from a wide swath of disciplines. Here a precis: Canada Goose sale

Among professors, 9.8% say don believe in God (this compares to 3% among the public as a whole), 13.1% say don know whether there is a God (4.1% of Americans as a whole). That makes 22.9% of the professoriat atheists or agnostics, compared to 7.1% of the public. In other words, in America irreligiosity is three times more pervasive among professors than among the public. To mitigate the sting of this statistic, Gross and Simmons aver that is by no means the most common stance toward religion of professors. frequency of other beliefs among professors includes do believe in a higher power https://www.getcanadagooseoutlet.com 19.2%; find myself believing in canada goose outlet in usa God some of the time 4.3%; I have doubts, I feel that I do believe in God, 16.6%; and know God really exists and I have no doubts about it, 34.9% (2% gave no answer).

canada goose clearance sale The canada goose parka outlet more the university, the more pervasive the unbelief. At doctoral universities, 36.5% of canada goose outlet store uk professors are agnostics or atheists, a figure that drops to 22.7% at doctoral granting universities and 15.3% at community colleges. Conversely, 44.5% of community college professors have no doubt that God exists, compared to only 20.4% of professors at elite doctoral universities. canada goose clearance sale

cheap Canada Goose As you might expect, the area of scholarship makes a big difference in the degree of belief. While only 6.1% of professors were atheists or agnostics, this figure was 29.3% for humanities, 32.6% for canada goose outlet store calgary computer science and engineering, 39.4% for social sciences, and a whopping canada goose outlet uk 42.4% for physical and biological sciences. When disciplines were divided more finely, biologists and psychologists nearly tied as the most heathen, with 60.8% of biologists and 60.9% of psychologists being agnostics and atheists, though there were relatively fewer outright atheists among the biologists. cheap Canada Goose

Canada Goose Coats On Sale I not sure how much succor canada goose outlet black friday sale these data can provide to those who worry about the incursion of atheism into universities. Yes, about half the professors are still religious though not among scientists but who ever thought that we were all canada goose outlet new york atheists? Canada Goose Coats On Sale

canada goose store Nevertheless, Gross and Simmons, in their discussion, are clearly heartened by the results, and just as clearly wanted to find a pro religion result. What kind of study is that? They note canada goose outlet 80 off at the end: canada goose store

uk canada goose outlet Whatever the outcome of these and other lines of future investigation, we have shown that religious believers are more common in the ranks of the American faculty than many strands of social scientific analysis and much popular discourse would suggest. uk canada goose outlet

Canada Goose Jackets And, at HuffPo, Amarasingham canada goose outlet in uk also breathes a sigh of relief: Canada Goose Jackets

What all of these data make clear, and future studies are sure to further complicate, is that the simplistic association of with is not backed by the evidence. findings call into question the long standing idea among theorists and sociologists of knowledge that intellectuals, broadly construed, comprise an ideologically cohesive group in society and tend naturally to be antagonistic toward religion, write Gross and Simmons. The idea that worldview of the intelligentsia is necessarily in tension with a religious worldview, is plainly wrong. In contrast, the evidence seems to suggest that instead of leaving religion behind, the intelligentsia, like the rest of society, rationally wrestle with ideas, scientific and religious, canada goose outlet official and attempt to find answers to the big questions that plague us all.

uk canada goose Never mind the three times greater irreligiosity among faculty than among the public, never mind the correlation of atheism and agnosticism with the quality of the institution: the faitheists and accommodationists can always spin the data to their liking so long as the correlation isn perfect and 100% of professors aren atheists. So much for the of sociology! uk canada goose

canada goose coats on sale Gross, N. and S. Simmons. 2009. The religiosity of American college and university professors. Sociology of Religion 70:101 129. doi:10.1093/socrel/srp026 canada goose coats on sale

canada goose coats What all of these data make clear, and future studies are sure to further complicate, is that the simplistic association of “intelligent” with “atheist” is not backed by the evidence. canada goose coats

canada goose uk outlet What a weird thing to say in reaction to this study. Now, I don like to assert even the vaguest correlation canada goose jacket outlet uk between atheism and intelligence, because I think it goose outlet canada sounds elitist, snobby, and in any case I know I would be susceptible to strong confirmation bias and therefore unable to objectively evaluate the evidence. some kind of peer pressure effect or something, or a third factor like regional distribution, or whatever. But the one way I can canada goose outlet store montreal see to spin the data is, That proves there no relationship between atheism and intelligence! Wha?!? canada goose uk outlet

On an unrelated note, I found the distribution across disciplines to be both interesting and extremely self satisfying. This kind of spin is ridicuously bad science.

But she didn show the math, because if she did, it be canada goose outlet in canada clear she just wrong.

cheap canada goose uk The association between scientific canada goose outlet uk sale achievement and atheism is just way too strong you assume that science is terribly racist and sexist and classist, and look only at white males from the middle class, you still see a huge association between science and irreligion. cheap canada goose uk

buy canada goose jacket cheap No wonder she doesn do any good factor analyses rather, doesn publish them. buy canada goose jacket cheap

Canada Goose online Exactly. It seems highly likely that some of the correlation between scientific achievement and irreligiosity is due to confounding demographic factors I may have even seen an analysis to this effect at some point, though maybe I making that up but canada goose outlet price in any canada goose outlet winnipeg address case, it clear as day that even if you factor that in, you still get a huge correlation so it in her best interests not to do the math. She can make a true assertion that confounding factors canada goose womens outlet do exist and get away with implying that it explains the canada goose kensington parka uk whole thing Canada Goose online.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *